Mar 252009
 

Cool news!  Demon’s Souls will be getting a native US release.  Own it in September for $59.99.  Pre-orders start July 8, 2009.

Demon’s Souls is a third person RPG for the PS3 made by From Software in Japan and recently released to the Japanese market. There was a lot of expectation surrounding this game and it landed white hot in the Japanese market selling out in its first day. Does it live up to all the hype? If it is only being released in the Japanese market, why would we care here in the US (or across the pond in Europe for that matter)? Can a Japanese console RPG really be that big of a deal? You have no idea.

Getting Started
This game features a comprehensive set of traditional RPG elements, but packages them with a Havok physics engine and state of the art HD graphics. Like most RPGs, your character develops based on a nicely simplified set of 8 character traits (vitality, strength, agility, etc) and you choose a character class to start in based on your expected gaming style. All the in-game equipment screens and character data screens are presented very clearly. In fact, I would have to say that I have not seen a better RPG user interface. Character creation is unlimited with all aspects of facial design accessible to the user for complete control (we took some old movie stills of Toshiro Mifune and modeled our character after Yojimbo). This level of control and tweaking is not necessary of course, but for those who like to create a unique identity, deep customization is a nice feature.

First Impressions
This game has an interesting basic dynamic. You have a physical body and a soul body. When (not if) your physical body dies, you continue as a soul body in a weakened, reduced, ethereal state. As a soul body, you can only get another physical body by harvesting demon’s souls, but since you are weakened, this necessary goal becomes a lot more difficult. One quickly discovers how precious life is and learns to guard it jealously.

Single Player vs Multi Player Modes
Essentially designed as a single player game, the player is not constrained to a single path nor a single goal. The player can “get involved” with various story lines if desired, with the player’s decisions and actions (or inactions) having an effect on the various NPCs and the game space. Player actions influence major game dynamics like the appearance (or lack thereof) of some monsters. Multi-player action is provided in a limited form allowing up to three players to cooperate in a mission, however two of the three players are only present in soul form and are somewhat constrained as a result. Further, players can forcibly “invade” another’s game as a soul and attack or hinder the live player at will. The constant appearance and disappearance of other player’s ghosts definitely adds an interesting dynamic to the game.

What’s Fundamentally New or Different in this Game
The Havok physics engine constrains weapons making for more realistic RPG game play. When your sword arm is pinned against the wall, you cannot effectively swing it. The Havok physics engine also means that when you slash at a wooden cart with barrels on it, the cart breaks exactly where you struck it and collapses accordingly. Let me pause for a moment and praise this game’s visual presentation. The loading scenes look like a motion comic with lushly detailed frames. The cut scenes are generated live making for consistent visuals throughout the game. The graphics themselves are nothing short of stunning (especially the lighting and smoke/particle effects) and are among the best I have seen. Lots of depth of field and visual complexity in the scenes, excellent lensing and cinematography. The voices and sounds are really rich and deep adding their own magic to the experience, especially in the echoing dungeon spaces. It is clear that a lot of time and effort went into the smallest details of this game.

Game Play Overview
Game play is really fantastic overall. You can wield various weapons and magics. You can wield and control left and right handed weapons separately. There are many different types of weapons (both melee and ranged) as well as many types of magic. There are also many objects that can be used as well. User control varies depending on the weapons or items wielded. Like many RPG environments you can only use items and weapons that you have equipped, no matter what is in your inventory. You have to equip on the fly, and if you are in a fight, that is time you might not have (just like in real life). Interestingly for an RPG, social networking aspects have also been integrated, allowing players to leave messages right in the game space for others to learn from. This is a fully realized RPG, not some stripped down console version of a paper game and not some button masher ultra combo attack game.

Details Matter
One aspect of the game play that I quite appreciate in particular is the real-time stamina factor. Monitoring and maintaining your stamina in this game is critical. You need a few seconds to regain your breath when out of stamina. You cannot simply swing your sword as hard as you can, over and over forever. After the third or fourth two handed swing, your stamina runs out. You’ll need to dodge or block for a second or two to get your stamina and strength back. This ups the fighting realism level quite a bit and does it in such a way that the stamina factor is effectively incorporated into the game without getting in the player’s way at all. Once you get a feel for what stamina level your character can maintain, you know what your attack cadence can be and you know when you need to dodge or block without having to watch your power gauges. It feels really natural.

No pausing! Life does not pause just because you need to read the directions and neither does this game. This seems to be by intent as you cannot even pause the game with the PS button. I have to say, this total elimination of the pause function takes me back to the days of Dungeon Master. I really like this a lot. It makes the game space and game time more real. This is no mere casual game. This is a game that demands your attention and requires your best efforts.

ds3Bring On the Bad Guys
Demon’s Souls really makes you learn what works and what doesn’t. The “normal” difficulty level is the equivalent of “extreme” on most other games. The fighting dynamic is relatively simple but satisfying. The enemy does use some basic tactics but if you don’t rush blindly into everything you can usually manage to pick your fights and heal between the smaller injuries. There are lots of zombie minion characters sprinkled everywhere you go. You also come across elite fighters from time to time and some of them even use traditional castle defenses on you such as rolling boulders down ramps and so forth. The elite fighters can also be quite difficult to deal with, especially if you are already in your weakened spirit state. They force you to adapt new tactics to overcome their superior strength and positions.

Who’s the Boss?
Ultimate game satisfaction for me always requires good bosses. The bosses (and even the mini-bosses) in this game are nothing short of incredible. Super tough and really awesome looking. Exceptional is not an understatement. The first mini-boss hits you one time and even if you were at full health, you are now dead. Now that’s a boss worthy of some respect! And this is just the first mini-boss, a 7 foot hulk with a club. All of the monsters and demons in this game are quite impressive. The dragon in particular is everything I could have hoped for in an RPG. There are even Godzilla sized demons that look like they can destroy whole castles in this game. The monster roars and you can see its facial flesh move around on its skull. You can see its throat and the separate muscles flexing in its neck. This game sets a very high bar in visual entertainment and presentation.

So What’s Not to Like?
Other reviewers have lowered their rankings of this game complaining that Demon’s Souls is too challenging and doesn’t do enough hand-holding. To these reviewers, I say that the Nintendo Wii is a very nice gaming platform and if you want a gaming experience that spells everything out for you, that environment seems to fit the bill. Personally though, I do not necessarily see a high level of difficulty as a deterrent to gaming nor as a negative factor by itself. So long as the buyer is aware that the game is challenging, and so long as the rewards of the game are worth the challenges.

A Serious Challenge
Demon’s Souls is hard, but straightforward. Beyond the obvious initial layer of this game is a surprising subtlety and depth that I just wasn’t expecting. From sight, to sound, to control, to game play, this game pulls off a very high level of environmental sophistication without a lot of complexity getting in the way of the user experience. This is exceedingly rare and it is these combination of factors that make this game so outstanding in an already exceptional field. It makes for the most compelling RPG experience I have had to date.

Overall, I give Demon’s Souls a solid 9+ out of 10 points and this is my game of the year (so far) on the PS3. Developed in Japan for Japan, this game might not be released in the US or in Europe (nothing has yet been announced), however you might be able to find the Chinese/English version at a Hong Kong gaming store. Get this game if you can. I am not kidding. If you have ever enjoyed an RPG and appreciate a worthwhile challenge, this game will ultimately thrill and impress you and will even satisfy the most hardcore RPG gamers. There is a reason why it sold 37,000 copies in the first week in Japan alone (and even caused a blip in PS3 console sales).

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

About Ken Trough

I'm a maker geek, computer modder, personal electric vehicle designer, homesteader, and cyberpunk. Gibson is good, but Stephenson has the vision and Snow Crash/Diamond Age are the clearest versions of the future I have seen yet. Knowledge is doubling every 18 months. As the rate of change increases the technology singularity approaches and our ability to predict the future utterly fails. What unimaginable future awaits us? This is a fascinating time to be alive.

  11 Responses to “Demon’s Souls – Big in Japan – The EPIC English Review”

  1. Excellent review! I bought this game and its incredibly fun. Its definitly going to be hard to beat as game of the year IMO. This game is EPIC!

  2. Holy Crap this looks amazing! Thanks for the very detailed review. Now where can I get this?

  3. Here are some sources from a wiki where you might be able to find the Chinese/English language version:
    Play-Asia
    NCSX
    Renchi
    Yesasia

    You could always keep an eye on ebay too.
    Hope this helps!

  4. Excellent review, and I agree the game is a 9+ :)

  5. It’s a great game, 10/10 here. If you cannot read Japanese you do not want the JP version. The Asian/Chinese version has complete english text and voice in-game.

    The controls are really easy once you understand how combat works within the havok engine too, some people complained but it can’t be more simple than it is.

    hk-wan on ebay sold me the one and it took about 12 business days from Hong Kong. It may never show up as a N. America release, From Software never ported 2 PSP games either: King’s Field Additional I & II which are both 1st person dungeon crawlers.

    If you like RPG’s, and don’t mind the difficulty level it will be a game you recommend to everyone.

  6. This game is great! I just got my copy yesterday (May 30th). i had to wait over a month for this, I ordered it back in the middle of April, but the Asian/English version was SOLD OUT, EVERYWHERE! That in itself tells you something! It means that the game was bought in its native countries and imported like crazy…when do you hear of a game being sold out, besides dumb gimmicks like wii-fit.

    This game is so impressive, when you first fire it up your jaw with drop from the visuals, you will be immersed from the atmosphere and if you are a RPG lover like myself, you will be grinning with joy. This game puts itself apart from everything else, and truly makes the ps3 shine.

    Why Sony isn’t releasing this elsewhere is crazy…Maybe they thought Americans and Europeans would be turned off from the difficulty and trend of easy-peasy baby games as of late? Maybe they just have too many games to publish too? Who knows, but the Good news is that you don’t have to wait for Sony to bring this over, you can import it now or…..WAIT TIL THE FALL 2009….. It has been announced that:
    ATLUS WILL BE BRINGING THIS GEM OF A GAME OVER TO NORTH AMERICA THIS FALL!!! Yes atlus has taken over publishing for english territories, and if you are an atlus game fan, like myself, you can bet that nothing will be cut. These guys deal exclusivily with niche rpgs from the East, they bring us some of the best games. Granted the games may not be mainstream, but you know what, that’s even better, True rpg fans have never been in the mainstream.

    This game rocks, and I highly reccomend it to any rpg player out there, hell even action adventure gamers would like this. Just keep an open mind in this game, because death is a big part of the game, you die, but you get better and try a different approach. It makes your experience points mean something (of course in this game , they can be stollen by enemy players entering your game and stalking you…lol…)

  7. [...] BoxNot to long ago our very own Ken wrote a very detailed and positive review of the Japanese game Demon’s Souls for the PS3.    The game is a ground breaking RPG which fans have had to import at their own [...]

  8. I’m a WOW junkie however in the past week, I have been having the same old kicked out of warcraft game due to the nightly shutdowns and maintenance. Being in Australia isn’t good – blizzard needs to stand up.

    So having all this time on my hands, I investigated rpg’s, imported into australia from play-asia and got this gem.

    OMFG! How addicting is it? I’m just getting used to it and have cleared the first act.

    I went to a medieval jousting weekend and saw some one on one combat.. this game is nearly so close to the real thing that I saw, I am now hooked on this.. Block, Parry, Swing, Stab, roll, jump back – Not just with same key – you can do any at any time – just make sure you have your stamina or you’ll end up puffing!.. It has something RPG’s dont – it isn’t button mashing, its tactics and each hit and block can be felt through the rumble..
    this game has fire explosions.. surround sound roars!.

    The flap of a dragon coming to breath and swipe at you while on a castle wall is exhilirating as you must time your run and stamina cooldown, zombies jump out at you in shadows…

    Blue eyed death knights swipe you so hard you have to run away if you don’t know how to block…

    Red eyed death knights one hit you…arghhhhh. I have died and died and died.. and am enjoying every death as i can now speed through that first level as my skill in fighting increased as I got to know how to do things like block/stab in tight corridors, or run and thrust in the open. Its simple things that are just so coool.

    And i haven’t even tried a magic user class yet… thats for the 2nd play through :) 10/10 from someone who has been playing games for 25 years… Last game I was this hooked on a RPG that isn’t WOW was 15 years ago (Dragon stone i think it was called).

    Thanks From!

  9. Thank you for the impressive post about Demon’s Soul. I would have to say that Demon’s Soul was the best PS3 game I played all of ’10. I really loved the art style plus how difficult the game was which made it an actual challenge. I am looking forward to reading more of your website in the future.

  10. This is a great game ever. It smacks down all games that I’ve ever have. great adventure and action along with nice graphics. I like this game so much…praise the founder of PS and this game
    LOL

Add Comment Register



 Leave a Reply

(required)

(required)

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>