
Alosar Emanli: Druid Mediocre
Reviewing products, especially gaming materials, is not an easy task. There is literally an entire universe of material to consider when looking at a product and saying, definitively: “this is good” or “this is bad”. It’s very easy to slip down the rabbit hole; for example, I could easily talk about the history of D&D 3rd Edition, and how that led to Pathfinder, which eventually led us to this product. And while I don’t expect anyone to buy or not buy this product based on my recommendation (I hate to think that folks’ livelihood is on the line here), I do want to always leave a few breadcrumbs so that you might find the rabbit hole.
The product I’m reviewing today is Paizo’s Pathfinder-branded Party of One BB3: Alosar Emanli and the Creatures from the Fallen Star. It’s a short adventure for, you guessed it, one player which follows the tale of Alosar, a druid’s apprentice, as he interacts with, well, the creatures from the fallen star. I can’t say the title isn’t spot on.
There have been two previous Party Of One supplements, so I imagine that the series has been received reasonably well. The previous adventures go for 2.99 on Paizo’s website, so I would assume that this product will be priced similarly. BB3 comes in at 15 pages, with about 12 or so being the actual content and the remainder being stat tables for your character.
I am going to be reviewing a number of products in the coming weeks, months, and years, so I imagine that some kind of standardized format would be in order. Since I am a massive nerd, I thought a lot about the best system to use: a larger scale allows for a more granular rating system, while a smaller scale is easier to understand. I also considered a buy/don’t buy recommendation system, but that recommendation relies on too much information I don’t have (your budget, your preferences).
I am going to break the review of products like these into three sections: Content, Mechanics, and Format. Content will include the meat-and-potatoes of many RPG products, the story. The Mechanics section will include my review of the mechanics of the product (and I will try to stay away from talking too much about Pathfinder’s mechanics in general, in this case). Finally, Format will include all the information about the physical/digital product, including layout, artwork, editing, etc. Yes, everyone’s favorite section, when I critique other peoples’ writing. Because mine is so awesome, of course.
Continue reading »
Popularity: 1%