Jun 212012
Rant, rant, charge. It is sort of like claw, claw, bite but more damage from the mouth.

Original image from WordRidden via flicker photo editing by Quinn Conklin

This week I am putting on my rant hat (just so you know)

There is something that has been bugging the crap out of me lately in fantasy games. It is the issue of race. The poster child for my problem is the typical D&D elven racial bonus with long bows. Why do they have it? What part of elven genetics says, ‘hey I am good with a bow?’

I mean, come on, let’s try to rationalize it. They have great eye sight? Or perhaps they are really dexterous? Both may be true, but why just longbows? Why is it that the eagle eyed elf picks up a short bow and is no better at using it than a human?

When you think about it, the logical explanation is cultural. Elves get the bonus not because of some gift of genetics, but instead because it is such a common weapon that most children grow up doing at least a little shooting.

Now as things go that is all well and good for explaining why, but it leads to another problem, or perhaps to an opportunity. It gives us a place to create unexpected kinds of elves in simple ways. The easiest way to make this sort of tweak is to just swap out the bonus. For example, think of elves who have lived in a dense jungle for years. Rather than every one of them learning how to fire a bow, they get a bonus to short sword from learning how to hack their way through the jungle with a machete.

There are a lot of places this can go, but let’s take a step back from making alternate elves and think about what other sorts of impact culture could have on races in a fantasy game. It could affect attitudes towards other races. It can and should affect skills other than just knowing a weapon or two. For instance, a gnome who grew up in a theocracy with a large dwarven population will come away from that knowing something about religion, speaking at least a bit of dwarven and probably have some strong feelings about both dwarves and religion.

Creating a few cultural tweaks to our fantasy races can bring our worlds to life with only a bit of work.

  4 Responses to “Notes From The Idea Factory: Rants, Culture and Classes”

  1. This is one of the reasons I have such a hard time with the simpler games like D&D, in it’s many incarnations, and lean heavily towards generic, point-buy systems. You want to play that gnome, knock yourself out – take a point in spoken Dwarven, a point in Theology and a quirk about being an avid debater of all things religious. Done and done, no muss, no fuss.

  2. That is a culture based thing and I have it be determined by the structure and environment of the elves in question, as you suggest, in my campaign.

  3. […] week over on Troll in the Corner I got on a bit of a rant about race and culture. Like I said I have thought about it for a while now and by a while I really mean since I started […]

  4. […] Notes From The Idea Factory: Rants, Culture and Classes at Troll in the Corner: Where the heck does a racial bonus with weapons come from? Do elves get longbows in the womb? […]

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.