Jun 142010
 

30th Anniversary Logo

When I first began gaming, I was the young kid breaking into a pastime from a bygone era.  Dozens of war stories from family and friends built up the mysticism of the hobby.  For years, my good friend and mentor would tell me about how he missed the glory days of gaming.  He’d tell me how new systems were so complicated and lost sight of what gaming was really about in a tangled nest of rules and modifiers.  And every now and then he would wax poetic about a game he missed from the old days, some little heard of system from the ancient times, Tunnels and Trolls.  We later discovered that the system is still very much alive.

What follows is not a review of the T&T system, but a simple (in no way comprehensive) retrospective glance at a game that has survived half a dozen revisions while staying surprisingly intact.  This is a breakdown of some of the basic concepts for rules and game play and a historical look at the game.

We start in 1975, one year after the release of Dungeons and Dragons first published edition.  The author of Tunnels and Trolls, Ken St. Andre, sought to develop a system similar to D&D, but simplified for ease of use.  The game was published by Flying Buffalo Incorporated, who to this day still licenses the product to its new publishers Fiery Dragon.

Like most first edition gaming paraphernalia, original copies are almost impossible to find.  Most players of the system have instead learned any edition between 5th and the latest 7.5 – released in 2008.  Savvy investigators may note that the game is actually missing the bridging 6thedition, instead making the leap to 7th and ultimately 7.5.  This is because the community for Tunnels and Trolls took over the game, adding house-rules from the designer and their own.  Several versions known as the Mythical 6th Edition started to appear, created by a growing fan base and one even published by third party company Outlaw Press, run by Jim Shipman.  While this version may have been part of what kept Tunnels and Trolls alive during the 1990s, it unfortunately has generated a fair amount of controversy as well.   In December 2009, Jim Shipman was asked to cease publication of the printed Mythical 6th Edition due to law suits Outlaw Press faced regarding art theft.  The RPG and artist community took a strong stance against Outlaw Press at the time.  Ken makes it clear that while all of the Mythical 6th Edition content is usable for Tunnels and Trolls, “Outlaw Press, despite their claims, has neither right nor sanction in publishing it.” -taken from an e-mail received from Ken on the matter.

The Mythical 6th Edition

Whether it is the notorious 6th Edition, rare 1st-4th, or brand new 7.5 Edition, T&T has managed to remain remarkably simple and true to its core ideals.  Three classes are available, a shocking option in comparison to modern day class overloaded RPGs.  Players may choose to be a Wizard, Warrior, or Rogue, which may then specialize later in their career into more specific roles and descriptors.   Other play options do allow for hybrid or otherwise non-standard classes to be chosen, including three new classes in the 7.5 Edition.  This is just one of the game’s many available adjustments, designed for maximum customization to a given play group.

In a similar nature to many other games, the Tunnels and Trolls character sheet features a list of attributes, which are rolled against to determine success or failure for a given action.  What is unique to the system is that most combat actions, aside from possibly magic or missile combat, are handled as a group rather than individually.  When the party melee attacks, all players attack together on each round of combat.  All melee dice are rolled at once, and the result added and compared to the result of the group of enemies.  This is an unusual mechanic and difficult to grasp at first, but speeds game play along to waste no time.  Sometimes goofy, spells in Tunnels and Trolls are generally open to a little haggling with the GM to determine exactly how they work.  It would seem that Ken St. Andre holds an interpretation of magic that is as whimsical as it is powerful.  Spell names like Take that you Fiend! and Hold that Pose!, coupled with melee fighters intended to be Conan-esque heroes, show the high fantasy inspirations the designer must have taken in.

In all of its iterations, Tunnels and Trolls is a system that leaves a great deal open to decipher.  The burden of storytelling falls to the Game Master, not the system; T&T forces GMs to put a little less work into monster preparation, but far more into rules interpretation.

In addition to rules revisions, T&T has seen the rise and fall of fan-made online magazines, comics, video games, and quality adventures.  The game has also innovated game play for Solo or Solitaire use.  This seems to be one of the greatest strengths the system has, having been easily adapted for small groups or one-on-one play, without even the necessity of a GM.  All of this adds to the game’s appeal for the casual play market niche.

It is important to note that Tunnels and Trolls was a game that was not created with the intention of milking money out of players, which it seems is a growing trend in any market in modern business.  Ken is reported as having said that he chose to make the game a six-sided die system, specifically for this reason.  Players simply could use what they could strip from board games and wouldn’t need to buy expensive dice packs.  Ken also runs a community at Trollhalla, where he consistently puts out week to week updates and content for his fans as a free service.  The mentor I mentioned above puts it best when he says that T&T is a game that has culture, and in the course of 25 years has kept that running as a driving force behind the game.

Afterword

If nothing else is said about the system, it is absolutely certain that no game exists like it.  T&T is a bizarre throwback to days long gone.  Even if the game play is a bit strange, a little goofy, and very different from what you know today, it represents a sort of underdog story that will never give up, and a long grown nostalgia for the gaming community.

Next Week!

Author and designer Ken St. Andre has agreed to an interview for Troll in the Corner, and we need your questions!  Post in the comments here, or at the Reddit link below, anything you might like to ask Ken, whether it regards the future of Tunnels and Trolls or what color socks he is wearing.  We’ll be back sometime next week with his responses.  We need you to make this work, so please do ask your best question, or ask several and we’ll pick the best!  Submit all questions by Friday, June 18th 2010.

Reddit Link!

Tunnels and Trolls 7.5 Cover

[tag]Retrospective, rpg, T&T, Tunnels and Trolls, role playing games[/tag]

About Nick Nundahl

I'm a wild haired demi-viking living on the East Coast United States. I've run games in countless systems and tanked more game nights than I've ever run successfully, but hopefully I learned a lot in the process and I'd like to pass that on. Follow me on Twitter.

  15 Responses to “Tunnels and Trolls: A Brief Retrospective”

  1. Updated with Reddit link.

  2. Ask him if there is any way to resist hold that pose. That’s always bugged me.

  3. Is it a d20 system? And where can you find out more about the system.

  4. I guess the obvious question to be asked it what are his thoughts on the release of T&T a year after D&D and a comparison between that two games. The other thing would be is that D&D is widely known for dorkdom all over the world. Does he think that if T&T was released before D&D would T&T hold that title?

  5. Great article, Nundahl! Happy to see T&T get this much-deserved coverage! I’ve posted my questions at Reddit.

  6. Ask
    What was the process to bring the game from a cool idea to print production. Also what is his favorite gaming system(besides T&T)

    Boxers or Briefs

  7. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Troll in the Corner, RPG Bloggers Network. RPG Bloggers Network said: Tunnels and Trolls: A Brief Retrospective from Troll in the Corner » Role Playing Games http://goo.gl/fb/1ixIz #RPG […]

  8. Can the Ranger also use a sword or a morningstar? Does he have an armor bonus (twice the normal protection)? Does he get one ADD per level like the warrior? In other words, is the Ranger a “Warrior Plus”, with all the normal warrior’s abilities plus the Missile Mastery Talent?

  9. Thor: the only dice needed is d6 (and you may need a bunch of them eventually). One of the easiest ways to learn about T&T is: http://www.freedungeons.com/. There is a free rules download (a scaled down version of v5 of the game) and a bunch of free solitaire adventures to try out. If you get interested, go to http://rpg.drivethrustuff.com/ to purchase the newest version and even more solitairs and GM games. Finally, check out Trollhalla.com (Ken St. Andre\’s website). GREAT folks online there to help answer ANY questions as well as some fun stuff gets posted daily.

  10. Hey Man, awesome article…ive never played T&T but now i want too. Well written, great job!! good luck in the interveiw!

  11. Great article, Nundahl. During your interview with Ken, please ask him, if the intent was to design a simplified system, why do the combat rules for higher level adventures require buckets of dice? It’s easy to create a huge monster, just write down MR 300. But that MR 300 monster now requires you to roll 31 dice. Some players might like rolling all of those dice, but for some it can be a turn off. And Grimtooth help you if you run into two or three of those MR 300 monsters.

    Also, in answer to Eric about resisting Hold That Pose: Resisting a spell is either automatic or impossible in T&T; there is no gray area, no rolling dice to see if you can or can’t. If your WIZ score is higher than the WIZ score of the caster, then you resist. Otherwise, you aren’t able to resist. So here we have a rule that is at the other extreme from rolling buckets of dice: NO dice are involved at all when determining magic resistance. (Okay, that’s not quite true…)

    Another question for Ken: Why did he think it best in 7th edition to make a change to the longstanding magic rules and require spell-casters to make SRs on INT to successfully cast their spells? Before 7th edition, spell-casters would cast, and they could feel confident that as long as they had enough Strength, their spells would succeed. In 7th edition, the magic battery attribute switched from Strength to a new attribute called Wizardry, which meant wizards didn’t have to be all buff any more, but he also added the requirement not only to have to exceed the WIZ of the spell’s target, but the wizard also has to make an INT SR or the spell fizzles. It’s a double whammy on wizards! It makes it much more difficult to take a wizard through a solo adventure in 7th edition and beyond.

    Now if you reflect back to the question about Hold That Pose, there are in fact dice involved to see if the spell affects you, but it’s not *you*, the target, that gets to roll the dice – it’s the spell-caster instead. I think I’d rather it had been reversed, that the target rolls the dice to resist and the spell-caster not have to roll. If the target is not one that can actively resist, then let the spell automatically succeed without requiring the wizard to roll the dice.

    Okay, I’ve said enough for now. I get a bit passionate about this game, as it’s the first rpg I ever played (back around the time it was first released). Thanks again for the article!

  12. Wow…this is a fantastic article! Khenn is definitely a master at maintaining the culture and magic of a game.

    One thing I would like to have him discuss, for GMs, are some tips and tricks to keep the magic alive in the game. I know we all have been part of good and not so good groups….but Khenn has more experience in this topic than, I’m guessing, the majority of the readers here…it would be nice to hear some advice from him.

    Great job Dude!

  13. Thanks for all the questions folks, if you have any more or know anyone who could benefit from giving the article a read, please pass it on. We could use some more questions to pick from!

  14. […] an often overlooked RPG that has been around almost as long as any other.  If you haven’t read last week’s retrospective, I recommend you start there.  This week, I’ve compiled a list of crowd sourced questions for […]

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.